Liberal councillor Julie Passas ordered to pay $11,000 over “wife beater” comments

·

Liberal councillor Julie Passas has been ordered to pay $11,213 to a fellow party member after loudly accusing him of beating his wife at a Liberal Party AGM four years ago.

Supreme Court Justice Stephen Campbell handed down the decision on Friday morning, describing Mrs Passas as a “well-known stirrer” and pointing out that in political circles people are often happy to dish it out but not take it.

The dispute unfolded at the Dolcissimo restaurant in the Sydney suburb of Haberfield, where about 30 people gathered for the annual Summer Hill State Electoral Conference AGM on the evening of March 29, 2016.

Robert Balzola, who was the president of the Five Dock branch and at the meeting as a scrutineer, alleged that in the course of the meeting Mrs Passas and Anthony Raciti, a party member and the owner of the restaurant where the meeting was held, made comments suggesting that he was a criminal who beats his wife.

Robert Balzola sued Julie Passas and Anthony Raciti for defamation over comments at a rowdy Liberal Party AGM. Source: News Limited.

He sued for defamation, and on Friday morning Justice Campbell found Mrs Passas did defame Mr Balzola and ordered she pay him $10,000 plus interest.

But the judge upheld Mr Raciti’s defence that he was responding to an attack by Mr Balzola, who accused him of being “part of the mafia” and spending Liberal Party funds on the restaurant.

Justice Campbell rejected Mrs Passas’ evidence that she had whispered the comment to friends, finding she had said them “loudly and deliberately enough for anyone close to hear over the din of the meeting.”

Mr Balzola has twice been charged with assault offences against his ex-wife. The first charges in 2008 were dismissed under the Mental Health Act, and the second in 2010 were dismissed by a magistrate. He had an AVO taken out against him over the 2008 incident, which was later revoked.

“It was a serious matter to accuse someone of perpetrating domestic violence,” Justice Campbell said, but he added Mr Balzola’s reputation would have suffered “temporarily” and the comments were only made to a room of about 30 people, many of whom didn’t hear them.

Mrs Passas was considered a “well-known stirrer.” Source: Daily Telegraph.

“The reality is that Mrs Passas’ statement was made in the heat of a rowdy acrimonious political meeting attended by a limited number of individuals in which milieu the trading of insults is often likely to pass as no more than an exaggeration of the cut and thrust of political exchange,” Justice Campbell said.

“It seems that in this circle Mrs Passas was a well-known ‘stirrer,’ or perhaps worse, which probably diluted the credence afforded charges emanating from her. Of course, in such an environment many individuals are happy to give personal offence as a form of political discourse, even if they are not so keen to receive it.”

The relatively small damages award of $10,000 was not meant to “trivialise” the matter or impose a Pyrrhic victory, Justice Campbell said, but rather merely reflected the “modest” harm suffered by Mr Balzola.

Mrs Passas said “not really” when asked if she had any comment.

“Who is not disappointed if they lose something?” she told NCA NewsWire. ”Even if it‘s your handbag, your shoes.”

Source: news.com.au.

Advertisement

Share:

KEEP UP TO DATE WITH TGH

By subscribing you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Advertisement

Latest News

Melbourne stage comes alive with innovative theatrical tribute ‘Alexander’s Journey’

An audience that filled every seat at the Clocktower Centre on 29 June was treated to Alexander’s Journey.

New Committee elected as NUGAS Victoria charts vision for youth and culture in 2025–26

On 26 May the Victorian branch of the National Union of Greek Australian Students held its Annual General Meeting to elect a new committee.

Gold Coast driver Alexander Vadeikis faces court over fatal street race

Gold Coast man Alexander James Vadeikis, 21, has faced court after being hit with upgraded charges over a deadly alleged street race.

Moray & Agnew named finalist in the Australian Law Awards

Moray & Agnew has been named as a finalist in the Lawyers Weekly Australian Law Awards for three categories.

Professor Andreas Evdokiou steps down after a decade leading Cyprus Community of SA

Professor Andreas Evdokiou has stepped down from his role as President of the Cyprus Community of South Australia after ten years.

You May Also Like

Health minister affirms Greece shielded against coronavirus

The Greek authorities have taken every measure to protect the country against the spread of the new coronavirus, Health Minister Vassilis Kikilias said on Monday, as the death toll in neighbouring Italy climbed to five.

EU to toughen sanctions on Turkish drilling, draft summit statement says

The EU will impose sanctions on more Turkish individuals and companies responsible for drilling in contested waters in the Mediterranean

Greece releases video of Turkish coast guard violently pushing refugees

Greece's Migration Minister, Notis Mitarakis, released a video that allegedly shows Turkey’s Coast Guard violently pushing a boat of refugees.