Insight or Perspective: Nationality and Myth


By Eleni Elefterias

A year ago I was in the audience at a panel discussion on the Macedonian question at the time of the Prespa agreement. I was sitting behind some very extreme people from North Macedonia who were making some very provocative comments regarding Alexander the Great. The Greeks in the room were quite reserved I thought and dignified in their responses to some outrageous claims by these people.

Though, I can understand the issue that these people have lived in that area for hundreds of years and though they have no claim to Alexander the Great or Ancient Greek history, they have every right to call themselves Macedonian just as we who live here in Australia have every right to call ourselves Australians.

There was mention that nationalisms are built on mythology. This is very true and especially in the Balkans there is a great problem of identity related to all the border changes, population movements and migrations and also the ethnic cleansing in the area. In fact, anthropologist Lorin Darforth , writes “How can a woman give birth to on Greek and one Macedonian”.

And yet this has been an issue in the area for decades. One example is that of the early filmakers of the 1900s, the Manakia brothers of Macedonia, one thought of himself as a Slavo-Macedon and the other as a Greek! Apparently, this is a “Balkan peculiarity” as Durham writes in 1905 and is quoted in the book Identity and the Nation, an example of which is a man who told him that “he was a Greek, but he was in Bulgaria, his father was a Serbian, and his children Montenegrin.”

All nations are built on mythology. What I said with a laugh to the extreme Slavo-Macedonian nationalist in front of me was that “We Greeks are just better at it!”




By subscribing you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Latest News

SYRIZA leader Stefanos Kasselakis visits Palestine to advocate for state recognition

Main opposition SYRIZA-Progressive Alliance leader Stefanos Kasselakis is visiting Palestine from Sunday until Monday, May 26-27.

Panathinaikos BC become European champions for seventh time

Panathinaikos BC has added a seventh European crown to its glorious history after beating Real Madrid in Berlin’s final on Sunday.

Mykonos shop owner reflects on Australia, Greece and crystals

Greek Australian, Apostolos Triantafyllou, 56, has been living in Mykonos for over 30 years now, and running his jewellery store 'Amethyst'.

Niki Louca shares her recipe for chicken pie with mushrooms

Niki Louca from My Greek Kitchen shares her favourite recipe for kotopita with manitaria (chicken pie with mushrooms) with The Greek Herald.

Dr Trakakis to give lecture in Melbourne on the late poet Tasos Leivaditis

Dr Nick Trakakis will give a seminar on Thursday, May 30 at the Greek Centre in Melbourne on the late poet Tasos Leivaditis.

You May Also Like

Peloponnese villages ordered to evacuate as fires burn on the outskirts of Patras

Villages in the northeastern Peloponnese have been evacuated following the fire that broke out in the area early on Wednesday.

Greece reveals “Macedonia The Great” trade logo

Greece on Thursday unveiled a new export trademark for products from its northern region of Macedonia, to counter competition from neighbouring North Macedonia.

Greek Australians remember slaughter of Pontian Greeks at the Australian Hellenic Memorial

Greek Australians remember slaughter of Pontian Greeks but few politicians are present. Mary Sinanidis reports for The Greek Herald.